True Confessions: The “We’re Just Friends” Lie

The Hyperion lobby felt unusually empty once Fred and Gunn finally left. They’d been lingering by the front doors for twenty minutes—Gunn calling her “sweetheart” in that low, easy voice, Fred blushing and tucking herself against his side like she belonged there. It was disgustingly cute. The kind of obvious, uncomplicated happiness that made Cordelia’s chest ache in ways she didn’t want to examine too closely.

She stood at the reception desk, arms crossed, watching the doors swing shut behind them. “Well. That was adorable.”

Angel leaned against the counter a few feet away, arms folded, expression unreadable. He’d been quieter than usual all evening.

Cordelia forced a bright smile. “I mean, I’m really happy for them. They deserve this. After everything… it’s nice to see something go right around here for once.”

“Yeah,” Angel said quietly. “Nice.”

The silence stretched. Cordelia busied herself straightening a stack of already-straight files. The honesty pact they’d been keeping for weeks had made almost everything easier—except this. Especially this.

She finally huffed out a breath. “Okay, fine. It’s not just nice. It’s… annoying.”

Angel’s head turned toward her.

“I’m happy for them,” she clarified quickly. “I am. But watching them be all open and obvious and together while we’re still pretending we’re just… you know…” She waved a hand between them. “Friends. It sucks.”

Angel didn’t look away. “We are friends.”

Cordelia laughed, but it came out sharp. “Oh, please. We haven’t been ‘just friends’ since the night you pinned me against that wall. Or the night you bought me half of Rodeo Drive because you had ‘specific ideas’ about how I’d look in the clothes. Or the midnight snack pact where we basically admitted we can’t stop thinking about each other.” She turned to face him fully. “We’ve been lying to the team for months. ‘Oh, it’s just Cordy and Angel, they’re close, that’s all.’ And we’ve been lying to ourselves even longer.”

The words finally hit the air between them and stayed there.

Angel’s jaw tightened, but he didn’t deny it. Instead he pushed off the counter and took a slow step closer. “You’re right.”

Cordelia blinked. She’d expected more resistance. “I am?”

“Yeah.” His voice was low, rough. “I’ve been telling everyone—including myself—that we’re just friends. That this is still the same partnership it’s always been. That nothing’s changed.” He took another step. “But everything’s changed. And I’m tired of pretending it hasn’t.”

Her heart slammed against her ribs. She didn’t move as he closed the last bit of distance between them. They were standing too close now, the kind of close that made the rest of the lobby disappear.

“I keep waiting for one of them to call us on it,” she whispered. “Fred gives me these little knowing looks sometimes. Gunn just smirks. And I smile back like I have no idea what they’re talking about. But I do. We both do.”

Angel’s eyes held hers—dark, intense, and completely unguarded. The charged eye contact felt heavier than any touch they’d shared so far. It stripped away every last layer of the lie they’d been clinging to.

“We passed the point of no return a long time ago,” he said, so quietly it was almost a breath. “Didn’t we?”

Cordelia swallowed hard. She couldn’t look away. Didn’t want to. “Yeah. We did.”

Neither of them moved. The air between them crackled, thick and electric, the honesty finally laid bare. No more jokes. No more half-truths. Just the two of them standing in the quiet Hyperion, staring at each other like the rest of the world had ceased to exist.

For once, neither of them ran.

The End.

True Confessions Home Page  |   Site Home Page  |   Next True Confession Story

Kudos & Critiques
Leave a note for Lysa about the story.